Hi all,
I've been offered a few Malaysian Trumpet Snails but I know they're a bit marmite with people.
I was wondering...
Would they eat Black beard algae?
How rapidly do they reproduce? (Granted you avoid overfeeding)
Are they a big help with turning sand over?
Cheers
Malaysian Trumpet Snails - friend or foe?
-
- Previous TOTM Winner
- Posts: 2154
- Joined: Mon Sep 14, 2020 16:19 pm
- Location: Truro, UK
- Has liked: 696 times
- Been liked: 1686 times
Friend in my opinion, but I think "pest" snails are massively underrated, MTS, bladders and ramshorns are all welcome here. Anyway:
BBA - probably not at they largely just hang around the substrate and clean that up. MTS can actually indicate an issue with water if they all head up the glass towards the surface. I wouldn't want them if I had a plant substrate capped with sand however.
Reproduction - Same as the other pest snails.
Turning sand - Massively yes.
I would say if you don't like pest snails, MTS are not for you but if you can see the value of these types of snails in the mini ecosystems we strive to create, then get a few.
Ps. Don't pay for them as your LFS would probably give you some, with a weird look for asking.
BBA - probably not at they largely just hang around the substrate and clean that up. MTS can actually indicate an issue with water if they all head up the glass towards the surface. I wouldn't want them if I had a plant substrate capped with sand however.
Reproduction - Same as the other pest snails.
Turning sand - Massively yes.
I would say if you don't like pest snails, MTS are not for you but if you can see the value of these types of snails in the mini ecosystems we strive to create, then get a few.
Ps. Don't pay for them as your LFS would probably give you some, with a weird look for asking.
Instagram - @the.cornish.fishkeeper
- plankton
- Super Mod
- Posts: 12248
- Joined: Sun Jan 21, 2018 17:02 pm
- Location: S. Derbyshire
- Has liked: 5048 times
- Been liked: 3422 times
I like them.
- Sixo
- Posting Legend
- Posts: 951
- Joined: Wed Aug 07, 2019 14:46 pm
- Has liked: 530 times
- Been liked: 310 times
I think If ever there was a snail for my tank it is the Malaysian Trumpet, I have sand and only use root tabs for my plants, will Corys be bothered by them?
I don't mind the idea of a few of them in there but I don't want to be carrying out regularl mass-cullings, that's the main put-off for me.
I don't mind the idea of a few of them in there but I don't want to be carrying out regularl mass-cullings, that's the main put-off for me.
- plankton
- Super Mod
- Posts: 12248
- Joined: Sun Jan 21, 2018 17:02 pm
- Location: S. Derbyshire
- Has liked: 5048 times
- Been liked: 3422 times
That pic is from the panda/guppy tank.
They do eat fish eggs though, that's the only con I've found.
They do eat fish eggs though, that's the only con I've found.
- Stephen
- Guru Multi TOTM Winner
- Posts: 6023
- Joined: Thu Mar 29, 2018 15:42 pm
- Location: Hereford, Herefordshire
- Has liked: 1418 times
- Been liked: 3409 times
- Contact:
To me all snails are unwanted.
Somehow a few (maybe 3 or 4) very tiny MTS were introduced by mistake (came in with some Corydoras) and soon I had hundreds.
I literally cleaned my aquarium out of everything and started again just to get rid of the snails.
Get some shrimp instead.
All the best
Somehow a few (maybe 3 or 4) very tiny MTS were introduced by mistake (came in with some Corydoras) and soon I had hundreds.
I literally cleaned my aquarium out of everything and started again just to get rid of the snails.
Get some shrimp instead.
All the best
425L SeaBray Elite aquarium - Rio Mamoré (Bolivia) theme
4 x Cupid Cichlids, 14 x Cory caudimaculatus, 12 x Cory sterbai 51 x Reed Tetra, 4 x Honeycomb Bristlenose (L519)
Powered by EHEIM
4 x Cupid Cichlids, 14 x Cory caudimaculatus, 12 x Cory sterbai 51 x Reed Tetra, 4 x Honeycomb Bristlenose (L519)
Powered by EHEIM
-
- TOTM Winner
- Posts: 895
- Joined: Thu Aug 08, 2019 10:17 am
- Has liked: 438 times
- Been liked: 844 times
- Contact:
I've got MTS in my big tank with fine sand. Barely see them these days except if I turn a light on at night and they're all over the place. Spend the daytime churning up the sand. Deffo don't eat BBA sadly
- fr499y
- Admin - TOTM Winner
- Posts: 8356
- Joined: Sun Jan 28, 2018 16:04 pm
- Location: West Midlands
- Has liked: 1785 times
- Been liked: 4200 times
for algae ( pram and tank mates dependant! ) you can't beat Otocinclus and Amano shrimp
-
- Previous TOTM Winner
- Posts: 22
- Joined: Sun Jan 31, 2021 23:37 pm
- Location: NW England
- Been liked: 17 times
I think a few snails is always beneficial, particularly in a planted tank.
I’ve found that if the population gets out of control, it can be a sign of over feeding. Feed less and the population diminishes.
I also introduce the odd assassin snail once in a while which keeps numbers of “pest” snails in check. I occasionally find myself moving assassins between tanks.
BBA is a suborn algae, and in my experience, is not always taken care of by otos or amano’s. Siamese Algea eaters on the other hand devour it - the problem at the moment is finding them - they look very similar to the flying fox, which is a different fish all together.
I’ve found that if the population gets out of control, it can be a sign of over feeding. Feed less and the population diminishes.
I also introduce the odd assassin snail once in a while which keeps numbers of “pest” snails in check. I occasionally find myself moving assassins between tanks.
BBA is a suborn algae, and in my experience, is not always taken care of by otos or amano’s. Siamese Algea eaters on the other hand devour it - the problem at the moment is finding them - they look very similar to the flying fox, which is a different fish all together.
240ltr planted low tech
186ltr planted high tech
Various shrimp tanks
186ltr planted high tech
Various shrimp tanks